The Michelin Pilot Alpin 5 showcased outstanding overall performance, with exceptional dry handling and comfort. Despite its impressive capabilities, it was narrowly outperformed by the Pirelli in snowy conditions. As one of the oldest tires evaluated, it reaffirmed why it has been a longstanding benchmark in its category. The tire offered a balanced and predictable driving experience across all environments. While it fell just short of the Pirelli in snow tests, the differences were minimal. For drivers seeking a proven and versatile winter tire, the Michelin Pilot Alpin 5 remains an excellent choice.

The Pirelli P Zero Winter 2 showcased exceptional performance in snowy conditions, outperforming all competitors in snow-related tests. It also delivered excellent handling on both wet and dry roads, offering strong grip and predictability across various driving scenarios. The only minor downside was its slightly higher rolling resistance compared to the Michelin, trailing by 1.8%. Despite this, the Pirelli P Zero Winter 2 emerged as a top performer, sharing the first-place position with the Michelin Pilot Alpin 5. For drivers seeking superior performance in winter conditions, this tire proves to be an outstanding choice.

The Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3 secured a strong third-place finish, distinguishing itself as the specialist in wet grip. It delivered the best braking performance in wet conditions at all tested temperatures and excelled in wet handling scenarios. The tire also performed well on dry roads and featured low rolling resistance. Its main limitation was a slightly weaker performance on ice compared to the top competitors. For drivers in regions with predominantly wet winter conditions, the Goodyear UltraGrip Performance 3 is an excellent choice.

The Hankook Winter icept evo3 showcased impressive strengths in specific areas. It topped the charts in dry braking performance and exhibited strong resistance to deep water hydroplaning. The tire also delivered commendable results on icy surfaces. However, it fell short in snow traction, placing last among premium tires in this crucial winter driving category. While it may not match the overall balance of the leading competitors, the Hankook Winter icept evo3 still provides solid performance across several important metrics.

The Continental WinterContact TS 870 P proved to be a consistently reliable performer across a wide array of tests, frequently landing in fourth place. It earned the highest comfort rating among all the tires tested, providing a smooth and pleasant driving experience. The tire also demonstrated strong capabilities in deep water hydroplaning situations and offered low rolling resistance, which can contribute to better fuel efficiency. Despite its many strengths, the tire showed some vulnerability on icy surfaces, where it couldn't quite keep up with the top-ranking competitors. While it may not have led in most categories, the Continental WinterContact TS 870 P stands out as a solid and comfortable choice that delivers dependable performance across various driving conditions.

The Goodride ZuperSnow Z507 made a notable impression by offering the lowest rolling resistance among all the tires tested. However, it fell short in most performance categories, especially in critical areas like wet braking and hydroplaning resistance, resulting in a less enjoyable overall driving experience. As the budget-friendly option in the test, it was somewhat expected to lag behind the premium competitors in various assessments. Nevertheless, its overall performance and less refined handling make it difficult to recommend over higher-end options for drivers who prioritize safety and performance during winter months.