The Nokian Seasonproof 2 secures a test victory, demonstrating that mid-segment all-season tires can challenge premium competitors. It dominates in wet conditions and snow handling while delivering very strong dry performance, offering consistent and predictable behavior across diverse weather.

The Michelin CrossClimate 2 is a premium all-season tire that sets the benchmark for balanced performance, delivering exceptional dry braking and snow traction. It combines low rolling resistance for fuel efficiency with confident handling across diverse conditions, though wet surface capabilities are slightly reduced compared to the test winner.

The Debica Navigator 3 achieves a podium finish as a budget-segment all-season tire, delivering predictable and balanced performance across conditions. It excels in dry handling and offers the lowest rolling resistance for best-in-class fuel efficiency, though wet braking is a notable limitation.

The Kumho Solus 4S HA32+ is a balanced all-season tire that delivers consistent, predictable performance across dry, wet, and snowy conditions. It does not excel in any single category but provides competent handling without surprises, positioning it as a reliable budget-conscious choice.

The Vredestein Quatrac Pro+ delivers strong wet-weather braking and handling but falters significantly in snow conditions and fuel efficiency. This unbalanced performance profile makes it suitable primarily for regions with mild winters where wet pavement is the primary concern.

The Sunny NC501 is a budget all-season tire that delivers adequate dry and snow performance but demonstrates significant deficiencies in wet conditions. Its poor wet braking and handling, combined with high rolling resistance, place it at a competitive disadvantage despite meeting basic safety margins.