Autobild: Big Summer Tire Test R16 2024
In an ambitious endeavor to demystify the tire selection process for consumers, Auto Bild's 2024 summer tire test meticulously assessed 55 different models in the 205/55 R16 category, which is recognized as the most commonly purchased tire size in Europe, especially for compact vehicles. By evaluating a broad spectrum of tires, Auto Bild aims to highlight those that offer the best combination of performance, safety, and value, thereby steering consumers away from inferior products and helping them choose tires that will best suit their driving needs and enhance their vehicle's efficiency and safety on the road.
-
Michelin Primacy 4+ - Winner Recommended
· Summer · 2022 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer87 58Verdict:Dry Braking Treadwear Straight Hydroplaning Wet Performance Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning Noise Value Rolling Resistance Price Wet Braking Wet Circle Wet HandlingThe Michelin Primacy 4+ showcased a balanced, high-performance potential in the Autobild Big Summer Tire Test R16, delivering good handling qualities and short dry braking distances. While it demonstrated exemplary mileage and economic efficiency, its rankings in various categories indicated room for improvement, particularly in wet conditions and rolling resistance.
Mexico ·
Central & South America ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
Middle East
Test Score:1.3 -
Continental PremiumContact 7 Recommended
· Summer · 2022 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer95 53Verdict:Dry Braking Rolling Resistance Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling Value Straight Hydroplaning Price Noise Lateral Hydroplaning WearThe Continental PremiumContact 7 excelled in the Autobild Tire Test. Its performance on both wet and dry roads was exemplary, highlighting a premium profile. Despite its strengths, there were areas such as hydroplaning resistance and noise levels where it did not lead the pack.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:1.4 -
Bridgestone Turanza 6 Recommended
· Summer · 2023 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer80 62Verdict:Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling Wear Value Dry Braking Price Wet Braking Lateral Hydroplaning NoiseThe Bridgestone Turanza 6 demonstrated balanced driving characteristics, offering safe handling and commendable braking distances on both wet and dry surfaces. While it showed very good mileage, its performance in hydroplaning resistance and noise levels highlighted areas for potential improvement.
USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
Middle East ·
Oceania
Test Score:1.5 -
Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance 2
· Summer · 2020 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer85 64Verdict:Value Wear Noise Rolling Resistance Dry Braking Wet Handling Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Lateral HydroplaningThe Goodyear EfficientGrip Performance 2 stood out in the Autobild Tire Test for its exceptional mileage and noise levels, achieving top rankings in both categories. While it provided stable and safe handling and offered very good value for money, its performance in wet conditions and hydroplaning resistance was less impressive, indicating room for enhancement.
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
China ·
Southeast Asia ·
Middle East ·
South Africa
Test Score:2.1 -
Kumho Ecsta HS52
· Summer · 2022 · Passenger - High Performance Summer81 37Verdict:Dry Braking Price Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wear Lateral Hydroplaning NoiseThe Kumho Ecsta HS52 delivered a convincing performance with outstanding achievements in dry braking and handling, as well as wet braking and handling. It offers short braking distances on both wet and dry surfaces and is priced affordably. However, its rolling resistance and hydroplaning capabilities, particularly in lateral conditions, indicate areas for improvement.
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Oceania
Test Score:2.1 -
Firestone RoadHawk
· Summer · 2016 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer68 39Verdict:Wet Handling Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Price Wet Circle Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning Dry Braking Wear Noise Wet BrakingThe Firestone RoadHawk demonstrated sporty dynamic handling, excelling particularly in dry handling and showing commendable performance in wet handling and hydroplaning resistance. It offers good value for money with a competitive price point and above-average wear resistance. However, its increased rolling noise and less optimal wet braking performance suggest areas for enhancement.
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
South Africa
Test Score:2.2 -
Falken Ziex ZE310 Ecorun
· Summer · 2017 · Passenger - High Performance Summer77 41Verdict:Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning Dry Braking Straight Hydroplaning Rolling Resistance Wear Wet Braking Wet Circle Wet Handling NoiseThe Falken ZIEX ZE310 EcoRun stood out for its dynamic dry handling and exhibited good safety margins against hydroplaning. While it offers short dry braking distances, its performance in wet conditions and rolling resistance could be improved. Additionally, the tire's limited tread life and higher noise level compared to competitors indicate areas where enhancements could be beneficial.
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
South Africa
Test Score:2.3 -
Hankook Ventus Prime 4 K135
· Summer · 2022 · Passenger - Premuim Touring Summer79 50Verdict:Dry Handling Dry Braking Low Rolling Resistance Wet Handling Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Lateral Hydroplaning WearThe Hankook Ventus Prime 4 demonstrated dynamic driving behavior with strong performances in dry braking and handling. Its low rolling resistance is commendable, aligning with eco-friendly driving preferences. However, the tire's wet performance, particularly in handling and hydroplaning, as well as its moderate tread life, suggest areas where further improvements could enhance its appeal.
Central & South America ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
Middle East ·
Africa
Test Score:2.3 -
Toyo Proxes Comfort
· Summer · 2020 · Passenger - Ultra High Performance Summer72 42Verdict:Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling Noise Dry Braking Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Lateral Hydroplaning WearThe Toyo Proxes Comfort excelled in the Autobild Tire Test with its dynamic handling in both wet and dry conditions and short braking distances. It stands out for its quiet rolling noise and a moderate price level, making it an attractive option for drivers prioritizing comfort and handling. However, the tire's lower tread life and average performance in hydroplaning resistance highlight areas for potential improvement to enhance its overall value proposition.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:2.3 -
Dunlop Sport BluResponse
· Summer · 2012 · Passenger - Ultra High Performance Summer80 56Verdict:Lateral Hydroplaning Dry Braking Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wear Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling NoiseThe Dunlop Sport BluResponse demonstrated notable hydroplaning resistance and fuel-efficient rolling resistance. While its dry braking distances were commendable, the tire struggled with grip on wet surfaces, as seen in its wet braking and handling performance. Its position in noise and wear categories suggests a balanced offering but also indicates room for improvement, particularly in wet conditions.
Mexico ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
East Asia ·
South Africa ·
Oceania
Test Score:2.4 -
Fulda EcoControl HP2
· Summer · 2020 · Passenger - High Performance Summer66 33Verdict:Value Dry Braking Price Noise Lateral Hydroplaning Wear Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet HandlingThe Fulda EcoControl HP2, ranking 10th in the Autobild Tire Test, demonstrated commendable performance with short dry braking distances and excellent noise levels, indicating a quiet ride. Its mileage and value are particularly notable, suggesting good economic efficiency. The tire also performed well in lateral hydroplaning scenarios. However, its lateral guidance on dry roads and performance in wet conditions, especially in wet braking and handling, highlight areas where improvements could enhance its appeal and safety profile.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:2.4 -
BFGoodrich Advantage
· Summer · 2020 · Passenger - High Performance Summer70 45Verdict:Dry Handling Price Noise Low Rolling Resistance Dry Braking Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Wet Handling WearThe BFGoodrich Advantage tire demonstrated dynamic handling and a solid performance in dry conditions. Its quiet noise profile and low rolling resistance are notable, alongside an affordable pricing strategy. However, its performance in wet conditions, particularly in handling and braking, shows a tendency towards understeer, indicating a need for improvement in wet weather driving safety.
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Middle East
Test Score:2.5 -
Kleber Dynaxer HP4
· Summer · 2018 · Passenger - High Performance Summer73 45Verdict:Dry Braking Noise Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wet Handling Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning WearThe Kleber Dynaxer HP4 ranked 12th in the Autobild Tire Test, showing strengths in hydroplaning safety and dry braking. Its noise level indicates good rolling comfort, contributing to a pleasant driving experience. However, the tire's handling characteristics, particularly understeering in wet conditions, and moderate tread life suggest areas where performance could be enhanced to better meet driver expectations.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:2.5 -
GT Radial Champiro FE2
· Summer · 2021 · Passenger - High Performance SummerN/A 30Verdict:Value Dry Braking Straight Hydroplaning Price Wear Wet Handling Rolling Resistance Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning NoiseThe GT Radial FE2 offers safe hydroplaning qualities and commendable dry braking performance. Its standout feature is its very affordable price, coupled with a solid value proposition and reasonable wear performance. However, the tire's grip on wet and dry surfaces is average, and its rolling resistance is on the higher side, suggesting areas where enhancements could improve overall driver satisfaction and performance.
Central & South America ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Oceania
Test Score:2.6 -
Giti GitiSynergy H2
· Summer · 2021 · Passenger - Premuim Touring SummerN/A 29Verdict:Value Dry Braking Price Wet Handling Wear Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning NoiseThe Giti GitiSynergyH2 demonstrated reliable wet handling and proficient dry braking. Its pricing strategy is competitive, offering a good balance between cost and performance. However, the tire shows a tendency to understeer on dry surfaces and has a notably high rolling resistance, which could impact fuel efficiency. These factors, along with its noise level, indicate areas where the GitiSynergyH2 could be optimized to better meet the needs of drivers.
Europe ·
Southeast Asia ·
Oceania
Test Score:2.6 -
Pirelli Cinturato P7 (P7C2)
· Summer · 2020 · Passenger - High Performance Summer82 60Verdict:Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning Wet Handling Dry Braking Value Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Price Wet Braking Noise Wet Circle WearThe Pirelli Cinturato P7 C2 demonstrated strong performances in dry braking and handling, indicating dynamic steering capabilities. While it provided satisfactory results in wet handling and hydroplaning resistance, its wear rate areas of concern, especially considering its higher price point. The tire's rolling resistance is also higher than ideal, which could influence overall vehicle efficiency.
North America ·
Central & South America ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
China ·
Middle East ·
Oceania
Test Score:3.1 -
Nexen N Fera Primus
· Summer · 2019 · Passenger - Ultra High Performance Summer59 31Verdict:Price Wet Braking Wet Circle Wet Handling Noise Value Dry Braking Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning WearThe Nexen N Fera Primus exhibited good braking performance and dynamic handling in wet conditions, showcasing its strengths in critical safety aspects. However, its performance in dry braking and handling, along with its significantly lower tread life and economic efficiency, highlight areas needing improvement. The tire's rolling resistance and a hydroplaning capabilities in straight-line scenarios also suggest potential for better optimization to enhance its appeal and performance.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:3.2 -
Uniroyal RainSport 5
· Summer · 2019 · Passenger - Ultra High Performance Summer70 39Verdict:Wet Handling Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Lateral Hydroplaning Noise Dry Handling Dry Braking Wear Rolling ResistanceThe Uniroyal RainSport 5 excels in wet conditions, demonstrating good hydroplaning resistance and safe handling. Its performance in dry conditions, however, is less impressive, with lower rankings in dry braking and handling. The tire's noise level is commendable, and its wear rate offers moderate longevity. While it performs well in its niche of wet weather driving, enhancements in dry performance and rolling resistance could elevate its overall appeal and effectiveness.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:3.6 -
Maxxis Premitra 5 HP5
· Summer · 2015 · Passenger - Ultra High Performance Summer75 43Verdict:Value Dry Braking Price Lateral Hydroplaning Wear Rolling Resistance Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Wet Handling NoiseThe Maxxis Premitra HP5, ranked 19th in the Autobild Tire Test, offers commendable dry braking distances and respectable mileage. However, its performance indicates a delayed steering response and only moderate grip levels on both wet and dry roads. While the tire is positioned well in terms of wear and value, its wet handling and circle performance, along with high rolling resistance, suggest significant room for improvement to enhance driving safety and efficiency in varied conditions.
Mexico ·
Central & South America ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
China ·
Middle East ·
South Africa ·
Oceania
Test Score:3.7 -
Vredestein Ultrac
· Summer · 2021 · Passenger - High Performance Summer72 43Verdict:Dry Braking Wet Handling Straight Hydroplaning Wet Braking Wet Circle Dry Handling Lateral Hydroplaning Value Wear Noise Rolling ResistanceThe Vredestein Ultrac excelled in driving dynamics in the Tire Test, achieving top rankings in wet handling, hydroplaning resistance, and both wet and dry braking. Its performance in these critical safety areas is impressive, showcasing the tire's ability to handle challenging conditions. However, the Ultrac's significant drawbacks are its low tread life and increased rolling resistance, which could impact long-term value and fuel efficiency. While its performance capabilities are notable, these issues may affect its overall recommendation for consumers seeking a balance between performance and longevity.
Europe
Test Score:4
- Year
- 2024
- Tire Test Original Link
- Visit Website
- Max Score, points
- 1
- Tire Size
- 205/55R16
- Season
- Summer
- Auto Type
- Passenger
- List Type
- Professional Tire Test
- Region
- Europe
- Date added
- Mar 20, 2024
- Date updated
- Sep 20, 2024
- Infographic