Test World: Winter Tire Test R16 2020
The Finnish organization ran a comparative test of 21 studded and friction winter tires.
The new test conducted by the independent Finnish organization Test World involved more than twenty studded and friction winter tires belonging to different price brackets. As always, the tires were tested on ice, snow, and wet and dry pavement. In addition, the experts were evaluating their noise emission, environmental performance, and road holding ability on uneven surfaces.
-
Continental IceContact 3 - Winner Recommended
· Winter · 2019 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x86 51Verdict:Snow Braking Wet Braking Dry Handling Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Wet Handling Ice Braking Snow Handling Acceleration on SnowPositive: Short stopping distance and good lateral stability on ice (but a risk of a skid during an emergency maneuver). Good handling and overall control on snow. Good handling response on asphalt.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:8.9 -
Michelin X-Ice North 4 Recommended
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x92 52Verdict:Dry Braking Snow Braking Wet Braking Dry Handling Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Ice Braking Lateral Stability Snow Handling Acceleration on Snow Fuel Consumption Noise Wet HandlingPositive: Excellent handling response on ice — the tires maintain dependable grip in any situation, for example, when unexpectedly hitting an ice-covered surface while cornering. Good handling response and high safety level on snow. On wet pavement, the tires keep reliable grip during an emergency maneuver.
Negative: Prone to understeer on dry pavement. Increased rolling resistance.Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:8.9 -
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 9 Recommended
· Winter · 2017 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x83 50Verdict:Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Ice Braking Lateral Stability Snow Handling Acceleration on Snow Dry Handling NoisePositive: Excellent grip and very good handling response on ice. Good handling response on snow (the tires will not bring you any unpleasant surprises in any situation). Good road holding ability.
Negative: Inaccurate steering response and prone to abrupt loss of grip on dry pavement.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:8.6 -
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R3
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x84 54Verdict:Noise Dry Braking Dry Handling Wet Handling Ice Handling Fuel Consumption Snow Handling Lateral StabilityPositive: No prominent issues found. Short braking distance and great handling response on ice. The tires ensure reliable grip in any situation. Very good handling response and confident behavior on snow. On dry and wet pavement, the tire’s performance was above average, which can be considered a serious achievement because successfully combining high traction on ice/snow and asphalt is quite a tall order. The steering response was somewhat delayed, but the tires kept up stable grip on the rear axle during an emergency maneuver. Low noise emission. Low rolling resistance.
Negative: The road holding ability could have been better.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan
Test Score:8.3 -
Bridgestone Noranza 001
· Winter · 2016 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x75 36Verdict:Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Ice Braking Snow Handling Acceleration on Snow Dry Braking Fuel Consumption Noise Wet HandlingPositive: Good overall performance on ice (but if you make an abrupt turn of the steering wheel, the grip on the rear axle is not reliable enough). Confident behavior on snow.
Negative: Long braking distance on snow, dry, and wet pavementInaccurate steering response, and prominently prone to rear axle skid when driving on asphalt. Already an old model, and this is beginning to show through.Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:8.2 -
Continental VikingContact 7
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x90 55Verdict:Noise Snow Braking Wet Handling Ice Handling Fuel Consumption Lateral Stability Snow Handling Acceleration on Snow Dry HandlingPositive: Short braking distance and great handling response on ice. Optimum control in any situation on snow. Good handling response on wet pavement — the steering response is somewhat delayed but the tires ensure stable performance without any unpleasant surprises.
Negative: Prone to grip loss on the rear axle during an emergency maneuver on dry pavement.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
East Asia
Test Score:8.1 -
Hankook Winter i*Pike RS2 W429
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x83 40Verdict:Wet Traction Dry Handling Ice Traction Wet Braking Dry Braking Noise Ice BrakingPositive: Good traction on ice. Good handling response and reliable grip on wet pavement.
Negative: Relatively long braking distance and prone to oversteer on ice. Prone to oversteer on snow. Delayed steering response and average braking performance on dry pavement.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:8.1 -
Michelin X-Ice Snow
· Winter · 2020 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x82 57Verdict:Snow Braking Dry Handling Wet Handling Fuel Consumption Lateral Stability Snow Handling Acceleration on Snow Dry Braking Wet BrakingPositive: Short braking distance on ice (for non-studded tires). Good handling response and high safety level on snow. The tires keep up reliable grip on asphalt during an emergency maneuver (even though the steering response is somewhat inaccurate).
Negative: The steering response on ice is somewhat delayed — but the tires ensure stable performance in any situation. Relatively long braking distance on asphalt.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
China
Test Score:8 -
Linglong GREEN-Max Winter Grip 2
· Winter · 2020 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter x75 29Verdict:Lateral Stability Dry Braking Acceleration on Ice Ice Braking Dry Handling Fuel Consumption Wet HandlingPositive: Short braking distance on ice. Logic behavior on snow. Short braking distance on dry pavement.
Negative: Insufficient steering feedback and handling response on ice. Delayed steering response on asphalt. High rolling resistance. Unbalanced overall performance.Europe ·
Russia+ ·
China
Test Score:7.9 -
Goodyear UltraGrip Ice 2
· Winter · 2014 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x85 40Verdict:Snow Braking Dry Handling Wet Handling Fuel Consumption Lateral Stability Dry Braking Snow Handling Ice TractionPositive: Excellent traction and short braking distance on ice. Short stopping distance and good handling response on wet pavement. Low rolling resistance.
Negative: Relatively low lateral stability on ice, due to which the tires may lose grip during an emergency maneuver. Prone to understeer on snowInaccurate steering response on dry pavement (yet the tires tackle emergency maneuvers with no problem).USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:7.8 -
Pirelli Ice Zero FR
· Winter · 2015 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x85 40Verdict:Ice Handling Noise Acceleration on Snow Lateral Stability Wet BrakingPositive: Short braking distance on dry pavement.
Negative: Unstable behavior on ice and snow. At first, the tires demonstrate excellent lateral stability and handling response but then they may abruptly lose grip — and may recover it just as abruptly. Very long braking distance, relatively weak lateral stability and inaccurate steering response on wet pavement. Insufficient road holding ability.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
China
Test Score:7.8 -
Hankook Winter i*cept iZ 2 W616
· Winter · 2015 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x78 30Verdict:Lateral Stability Dry Handling Wet Handling Fuel Consumption Ice Handling Wet BrakingPositive: Logic behavior without any unpleasant surprises on snow. Low rolling resistance. On dry pavement, the tires demonstrate delayed response to the driver’s actions, at the same time ensuring dependable grip on the rear axis.
Negative: Unstable behavior on wet pavement. Risk of going into a skid during an emergency maneuver on ice.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:7.7 -
Kontio IcePaw
· Winter · 2020 · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter xN/A 19Verdict:Lateral Stability Acceleration on Ice Ice Braking Noise Snow Braking Dry Handling Wet Handling Snow HandlingPositive: Excellent traction and short braking distance on ice. Good road holding ability.
Negative: Low lateral stability on ice, due to which the tires lose grip on the rear axle during an emergency maneuver. Long braking distance, and prone to skidding on snow. Weak lateral grip on asphalt. High noise emission.Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:7.6 -
Sava Eskimo Ice
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter xN/A 25Verdict:Noise Dry Handling Wet Handling Lateral Stability Acceleration on Snow Dry Braking Wet BrakingPositive: Good braking efficiency on ice. On dry pavement, the tires ensure confident overall performance, keeping stable grip on the rear axle.
Negative: Prone to grip loss on ice (at high speeds). Inaccurate steering response on wet pavement (but the tires’ overall behavior is stable). Long braking distance on dry pavement.USA+ ·
Canada
Test Score:7.6 -
Linglong Winter Unicorn· Winter · 2020 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter xN/A 22Verdict:Snow Handling Noise Dry Handling Fuel Consumption Wet Braking
Negative: Delayed steering response on ice and snow (but the grip is rather strong). Poor grip and insufficient handling response on dry and wet pavement — the tires have problems tackling emergency maneuvers. High rolling resistance.
Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:7.5 -
Bridgestone Blizzak Ice
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x69 50Verdict:Lateral Stability Dry Handling Snow Braking Snow Handling Wet Handling Wet BrakingPositive: Good handling response on snow (but the grip is generally lower than that of the leaders). Well-balanced behavior and short braking distance on dry pavement.
Negative: Prone to understeer on ice and wet pavement.Europe ·
Russia+ ·
South Korea
Test Score:7.4 -
Nankang Ice Activa 2
· Winter · 2020 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter xN/A 22Verdict:Snow Handling Wet Handling Noise Acceleration on Snow Dry Braking Dry Handling Acceleration on Ice Ice Braking Lateral StabilityPositive: Acceptable handling response on snow (but the tires may lose grip too suddenly). Acceptable handling on wet pavement (even though the tires demonstrate a slightly delayed response to the driver’s actions).
Negative: Poor longitudinal grip on ice (lateral stability is slightly better). Poor traction and inaccurate steering response on dry pavement.Europe
Test Score:7.3 -
Nexen Winguard Ice Plus
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x68 37Verdict:Dry Handling Wet Braking Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Wet Handling Ice Braking Snow HandlingNegative: Poor grip on ice, both longitudinal and lateral. On ice, prone to skidding both on front and rear axles. Poor grip on snow during an emergency maneuver. Long braking distance and lack of control on dry and wet pavement. Insufficient road holding ability. Increased rolling resistance.
USA+ ·
Canada ·
Russia+
Test Score:7 -
Petlas Glacier W661
· Winter · 2019 · Passenger - Performance Winter / SnowN/A 20Verdict:Dry Braking Dry Handling Wet Handling Wet Braking Snow Braking Acceleration on Ice Ice Handling Ice Braking Snow HandlingPositive: Very high braking efficiency on wet and dry pavement. Very quick and accurate steering response on wet pavement (almost like summer tires); on dry pavement the situation is even better.
Negative: Very weak traction on ice. The tires can suddenly go into a skid, taking forever to recover grip and bring the car to a standstill. When cornering on snow, the tires on the front axle quickly lose grip, after which the rear wheels go into a skid as well. Insufficient road holding ability.USA+ ·
Canada
Test Score:7 -
Toyo Observe GSi-6
· Winter · 2018 · Passenger - Studless Ice & Snow · For Nordic Winter x69 38Verdict:Dry Braking Dry Handling Wet Braking Noise Acceleration on Ice Fuel Consumption Ice Handling Ice Braking Lateral StabilityPositive: Stable behavior on snow, including during emergency maneuvers (although the frip could be stronger). Short braking distance and good lateral stability on wet pavement (but delayed steering response). Stable behavior and short braking distance on dry pavement.
Negative: On ice, the tires lose grip too suddenly, which is detrimental to handling response. Insufficient road holding ability. High rolling resistance. Increased noise.USA+ ·
Canada ·
Europe ·
Russia+ ·
Japan ·
China
Test Score:7 -
Sunny SN3860
· Winter · Passenger - Studdable Winter / Snow · Studded · For Nordic Winter xN/A 4Verdict:Lateral Stability Dry Handling Wet Braking Snow Braking Fuel Consumption Ice Handling Ice Braking Snow Handling Acceleration on SnowPositive: Very short braking distance on wet pavement.
Negative: The grip on ice is virtually nonexistent, and the car keeps on drifting to different sides. On snow, the situation is just as bad. Poor lateral stability, delayed steering response, and unstable behavior on wet pavement (on dry pavement the situation slightly improves).Europe ·
Russia+
Test Score:6.3
- Year
- 2020
- Tire Test Original Link
- Visit Website
- Max Score, points
- 10
- Tire Size
- 205/55R16
- Season
- Winter
- Auto Type
- Passenger
- List Type
- Professional Tire Test
- Region
- Europe
- Date added
- Oct 17, 2020
- Date updated
- Feb 17, 2021